Outlander fans fume 'it's just wrong' as they revisit 'traumatic' season 5 scene

*Warning - This article contains spoilers for the Outlander television series and book series.*

enthusiasts have been debating a pivotal scene from season 5, with some arguing that it "trivialises" the traumatic experience of Roger Wakefield, played by Richard Rankin.

As the series prepares to return, fans have been dissecting previous episodes, with some criticising the decision to film scenes from episode 8 in a "silent film" style.

With season 7, part 2 on the horizon, a fan took to Reddit to express their discontent with the show's portrayal of Randall Fraser, played by Sophie Skelton, who is the daughter of main character Claire Fraser, played by Caitriona Balfe, and Jamie Fraser, played by Sam Heughan.

The Reddit user with the handle @Curious_Doctor_848 posted: "Geez, does Roger never catch a break?!

"Watching season 5, episode 8... I also did not like the "silent movie" way they did that. Seemed to gloss over a (yet another) traumatic and important event in Brianna and Roger's life/relationship." (sic)

Fans swiftly responded with similar sentiments, with one concurring: "I didn't like the Silent movie scenes as well. It was just odd..."

Another fan commented: "I agree. I think Roger gets the shaft. And that silent movie thing was such a stretch. It took away from the terror of what happened to him. Substance sacrificed for style points."

A third vented their frustration, saying: "Yeah the whole silent movie thing was really stupid. Like when Bonnet was robbing them and there was no sound, just that song playing. Dumb." (sic)

Another viewer expressed their dissatisfaction, adding: "I found the silent movie imagery just...wrong. It's not like Roger lived through the silent era. In the book, he is a fan of the silents but that connection wasn't made in the series. For me, it distracted from the horror of his experience."

An additional comment came from a fan who concurred: "I have to agree... I get the artistic part of it but I feel like something so important for his and Brianna's story (and honestly it contributes to other character plot lines too)... I just feel like it diminished the actual event quite a bit.

"Not sure if you've seen the whole series yet so I won't be specific to avoid spoilers but there's another event coming that they use similar technique... it was definitely a traumatic thing but I just feel like it was a little confusing." (sic)

However, some viewers appreciated the creative choice, with one explaining: "I understand why they did the silent movie style. Roger lost his voice and it plays very loosely into the time traveler aspect of things. But I did not enjoy it. I feel if they wanted to go that route, they should have done his recovery in a silent movie style but only when we switch to his POV." (sic)

One person countered the prevailing view, saying: "I guess I'm the outlier here, which is okay. I appreciated the silent movie style. I personally found it very eerie and chilling, it gave me goosebumps. It's something from the series that has stuck with me." (sic)

Echoing this sentiment, another added: "I really liked it too. I'm surprised by the opinions in here." While someone else highlighted: "In a traumatic situation, it is common for people to disassociate from the brutality. I thought it was handled in a sensitive manner."

Following the closure of Lionsgate+ in the UK, new episodes of Outlander will be available on Starz and to stream on Prime Video channel MGM+ from Sunday, November 22. You must be an Amazon Prime member before you can sign up for MGM+.